The Human Blueprint – Part three: The Cosmic Perspective, and the Search for Others

IV. The Cosmic Perspective: Rarity, Ubiquity, and the Search for Others

The discussion of human optimality and hypothetical alien forms is incomplete without considering the broader cosmic context. The probability of intelligent life existing elsewhere in the universe directly shapes our understanding of human uniqueness.

The Rare Earth Hypothesis vs. the Principle of Mediocrity

The scientific community grapples with two contrasting viewpoints regarding the prevalence of complex life in the cosmos:

• The Rare Earth Hypothesis:

  This hypothesis posits that the origin and evolution of complex, multicellular, intelligent life, such as humans, required an exceedingly improbable confluence of astrophysical and geological events.¹² Proponents argue that a particular set of conditions—including a galactic habitable zone, a stable central star and planetary system, and unique planetary characteristics—must align for such life to emerge.¹² For example, the large human brain, despite its advantages, carries significant adaptive disadvantages, such as high metabolic demands, a prolonged gestation period, and an extended childhood.¹² If the Rare Earth hypothesis holds true, the human form might represent an exceedingly rare, highly specialised “optimal” solution for a very particular and uncommon set of cosmic circumstances.

• The Principle of Mediocrity (or Copernican Principle):

  Conversely, this principle asserts that Earth does not hold a privileged or unique position in the universe.³⁵ Given the immense scale and age of the cosmos, the ubiquitous presence of life-forming elements like carbon and water, and the universality of physical laws, this perspective suggests that extraterrestrial life, including intelligent life, is highly probable.³⁵ Newer research even suggests that human origins were “on time” with the necessary environmental conditions rather than a stroke of luck, which could increase the probability of intelligent life elsewhere.³⁶ If the Principle of Mediocrity is more accurate, then other “optimal” forms for intelligence could be common, each shaped by their unique environments.

The debate between these two hypotheses directly informs whether the human form is a uniquely “optimal” outcome or merely one of many possible pathways to intelligence. The implications are profound: if humanity is a statistical anomaly, its form is uniquely optimal for its specific, rare circumstances. If life is common, then other forms are also optimal for their respective circumstances.

The Fermi Paradox: “Where is Everybody?”

The Fermi Paradox highlights a profound discrepancy: despite the seemingly high probability of extraterrestrial life, there is a striking lack of conclusive evidence for its existence.³⁷ Numerous proposed resolutions attempt to explain this silence. These include the possibilities that intelligent alien species are rare, that their civilisations are short-lived due to self-destruction, that they actively destroy other emerging civilisations, that they only broadcast detectable signals for brief periods, or that their forms of intelligence are simply too incomprehensible for us to recognise.³⁷

• The Zoo Hypothesis:

  One intriguing resolution is the Zoo Hypothesis, which speculates that technologically advanced extraterrestrial life intentionally refrains from contacting Earth.This deliberate avoidance is posited to allow for humanity’s natural evolution and sociocultural development, much like observing animals in a zoo.³⁸ This hypothesis implies the existence of a highly advanced, ethical, and powerful alien civilisation capable of maintaining such a non-interference policy.

• The “AI Filter”:

  Another theory suggests an “AI filter” as a potential explanation for the Fermi Paradox.²⁹ This concept proposes that the development of advanced artificial intelligence might represent a universal barrier or a transformative event that renders civilisations undetectable or leads to their short-lived existence.²⁹

Regardless of its ultimate resolution, the Fermi Paradox implies that the path to advanced technological civilisation is fraught with challenges. This suggests that the “optimal” form for long-term survival and interstellar expansion might be one that inherently avoids self-destruction, efficiently overcomes resource limitations, or even transcends biological forms entirely. The absence of observable alien civilisations could indicate that the human form, while successful thus far, is not inherently “optimal” for long-term cosmic survival or that truly optimal forms are simply beyond our current detection capabilities or understanding.

The Search for Extra-terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) and Techno-signatures

The scientific endeavour to detect intelligent life beyond Earth is embodied by the Search for Extra-terrestrial Intelligence (SETI), which involves actively searching for radio or optical signals from extra-terrestrial societies.³⁹ Astrobiology and exobiology are interdisciplinary fields dedicated to understanding the origin, evolution, distribution, and future of life in the universe, including the systematic search for biosignatures (evidence of life) and ‘techno-signatures’ (evidence of technology).³² Techno-signatures encompass remotely detectable evidence of extra-terrestrial technology, such as industrial pollutants (e.g., nitrogen dioxide from fossil fuel combustion) in exoplanet atmospheres or the presence of large-scale megastructures like Dyson spheres.³¹ Conversely, Messaging Extra-terrestrial Intelligence (METI) involves the deliberate transmission of signals from Earth into space.³³ Notable past attempts include the Pioneer and Voyager probes, which carried etched plaques and golden records depicting the human form, the solar system, and basic scientific concepts.³³ The Arecibo message, transmitted in 1974, was a 1,679-pixel bitmap designed to convey fundamental mathematical and physical concepts.³³

Our current search for extra-terrestrial intelligence is primarily based on the assumption that alien civilisations will follow a technological trajectory somewhat analogous to our own, leaving detectable “techno-signatures” that are either a by-product or an intentional communication of their advanced state. This implicitly acknowledges that human technological development, while perhaps not universally optimal, represents a plausible and detectable pathway for intelligent life. The reliance on mathematical and pictorial communication in METI efforts also assumes a shared foundation of cognitive and sensory frameworks, suggesting that despite potential morphological differences, there might be universal principles of logic and perception that transcend specific biological forms.

V. Conclusion: Reassessing Human Uniqueness and Future Trajectories

The inquiry into whether the human body is the “optimal” form for intelligent life capable of achieving complex societies and advanced technology reveals a nuanced perspective. The human form is not universally “optimal” in an absolute sense but rather a highly effective, context-specific solution that maximises the benefits of intelligence and manipulation while managing its inherent biological costs on Earth. Its “optimality” lies in the synergistic co-evolution of its unique traits: bipedalism frees the hands, the dexterous hand drives brain development and tool use, and the expanding brain fosters complex language. This interconnected system created a powerful positive feedback loop for technological and societal advancement within Earth’s specific environmental and evolutionary context.⁸ While successful, the human form does carry significant biological costs, such as the high metabolic demand of a large brain and the vulnerabilities inherent to its organic composition.¹² The concept of “optimal intelligence” is not static; it is actively evolving on Earth through human augmentation and the rapid development of artificial intelligence. Humanity is not merely a passive product of evolution but an active agent in its own biological and cognitive transformation. Through transhumanist endeavours, humans are augmenting their biological forms and cognitive abilities, potentially blurring the lines between biological and artificial intelligence.⁷ Artificial intelligence, in particular, presents a novel form of intelligence with distinct advantages in processing speed, data analysis, and risk reduction that biological life cannot inherently match.²⁴ This suggests that future “optimal” intelligences might be post-biological or hybrid entities. This implies that even if the current human biological form were considered “optimal” for its current state of development, it is a transient condition, as humanity itself is striving to surpass it, raising profound questions about the future of intelligence and its physical manifestation. From a cosmic perspective, the ultimate “optimal” form for intelligent life capable of achieving complex societies and advanced technology on a grand scale remains an open question. Scientific speculation considers a vast array of alternative biological and non-biological intelligent forms, each potentially “optimal” for its unique environment and evolutionary pressures.¹⁵ The Fermi Paradox, with its perplexing silence from the cosmos, highlights the immense challenges or inherent rarity of advanced technological civilisations, suggesting that the path to cosmic longevity might require forms of intelligence or societal structures currently beyond human comprehension or technological reach.²⁹ The ongoing search for extraterrestrial life and technosignatures continues, driven by the profound implications of discovering intelligence that may surpass human capabilities. Such a discovery would fundamentally challenge anthropocentric views and significantly expand our understanding of life’s potential in the universe.³² Humanity’s journey serves as a compelling case study of a successful evolutionary pathway to advanced intelligence. Still, it is not necessarily the definitive blueprint for universal intelligence.

<<The Human Blueprint – Part Two: Beyond Human: Exploring Hypothetical Intelligent Life Forms<<

Works cited

1. The Biology of Survival | For Humanity, https://forhumanity.yale.edu/news/biology-survival
2. Functions of Life | BioNinja, https://old-ib.bioninja.com.au/standard-level/topic-1-cell-biology/11-introduction-to-cells/functions-of-life.html
3. en.wikipedia.org, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimality_model#:~:text=In%20biology%2C%20optimality%20models%20are,other%20aspects%20of%20its%20phenotype.
4. Optimality model – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimality_model
5. anthroholic.com, https://anthroholic.com/complex-societies#:~:text=Five%20characteristics%20of%20a%20complex,technology%2C%20and%20a%20written%20language.
6. Characteristics of a Civilization – Students of History, https://www.studentsofhistory.com/characteristics-of-a-civilization
7. A Complete Guide to Human Augmentation Technology – Imaginovation, https://imaginovation.net/blog/human-augmentation-technology-guide/
8. The Hand, the Brain and Man’s Travel in Time | Neupsy Key, https://neupsykey.com/the-hand-the-brain-and-mans-travel-in-time/
9. Human evolution – Bipedalism, Adaptations, Fossils | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/science/human-evolution/Theories-of-bipedalism
10. Evolution of human intelligence – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_of_human_intelligence
11. Theory of multiple intelligences – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligences
12. Rare Earth hypothesis – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_Earth_hypothesis
13. Speech Evolution, or Why Humans are Awesome – Speech Buddies, https://www.speechbuddy.com/blog/news/speech-evolution-origin-of-language-humans-are-awesome/
14. How do we know if they could speak? – The Australian Museum, https://australian.museum/learn/science/human-evolution/how-do-we-know-if-they-could-speak/
15. Hypothetical types of biochemistry – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemistry
16. How Aliens Work – Science | HowStuffWorks, https://science.howstuffworks.com/space/aliens-ufos/alien-physiology.htm
17. Why is it believed that a non-carbon based life form cannot exist? : r/AskScienceDiscussion, https://www.reddit.com/r/AskScienceDiscussion/comments/as9hwa/why_is_it_believed_that_a_noncarbon_based_life/
18. Does silicon-based life exist? | www.the-ies.org, https://www.the-ies.org/analysis/does-silicon-based-life-exist
19. What would a silicon based species be like? : r/worldbuilding – Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/worldbuilding/comments/5p10ab/what_would_a_silicon_based_species_be_like/
20. Weird Life | HowStuffWorks, https://science.howstuffworks.com/weird-life.htm
21. The similarity of life across the universe – PMC, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4865312/
22. Precambrian body plans – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precambrian_body_plans
23. Would intelligent life evolve any other body plan than humanoid? – Worldbuilding Stack Exchange, https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/25209/would-intelligent-life-evolve-any-other-body-plan-than-humanoid
24. 20+ Advantages and Disadvantages of AI | Pros of Artificial Intelligence – Simplilearn.com, https://www.simplilearn.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-artificial-intelligence-article
25. What Is Artificial Intelligence (AI)? – IBM, https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/artificial-intelligence
26. Applications of artificial intelligence – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Applications_of_artificial_intelligence
27. Technological singularity – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity
28. Artificial Intelligence Playbook for the UK Government (HTML) – GOV.UK, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/ai-playbook-for-the-uk-government/artificial-intelligence-playbook-for-the-uk-government-html
29. Superintelligence: Identification of Friend or Foe Future Landscape of Cooperation with Non-human Intelligence – Qeios, https://www.qeios.com/read/QC239X
30. Transhumanism and Human Enhancement — A Journey Beyond Human Limits, https://www.gsdvs.com/post/transhumanism-and-human-enhancement-a-journey-beyond-human-limits
31. Intelligent aliens would need a power supply to jump-start their civilization — would they require fossil fuels? | Live Science, https://www.livescience.com/space/extraterrestrial-life/intelligent-aliens-would-need-a-power-supply-to-jumpstart-their-civilization-would-they-require-fossil-fuels
32. Why we’re searching for alien tech in the solar system | Aeon Essays, https://aeon.co/essays/why-were-searching-for-alien-tech-in-the-solar-system
33. Communication with extraterrestrial intelligence – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communication_with_extraterrestrial_intelligence
34. Interacting with Advanced Extraterrestrial Intelligence: Pros and Cons, https://newspaceeconomy.ca/2024/10/19/interacting-with-advanced-extraterrestrial-intelligence-pros-and-cons/
35. Extraterrestrial life – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraterrestrial_life
36. Does planetary evolution favor human-like life? Study ups odds we’re not alone – Penn State, https://www.psu.edu/news/research/story/does-planetary-evolution-favor-human-life-study-ups-odds-were-not-alone
37. Fermi paradox – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox
38. Zoo hypothesis – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis
39. Third IAA Symposium on Searching for Life Signature – МГУ, http://lnfm1.sai.msu.ru/SETI/koi/books/st-petersburg.pdf
40. New on The Conversation: Extraterrestrial life may look nothing like life on Earth − so astrobiologists are coming up with a framework to study how complex systems evolve | University of Arizona News, https://news.arizona.edu/employee-news/new-conversation-extraterrestrial-life-may-look-nothing-life-earth-so-astrobiologists
41. Exobiology: The NASA Program, https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19930009372/downloads/19930009372.pdf
42. Astrobiology – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrobiology
43. ASTROBIOLOGY: The Study of the Living Universe – Christopher F. Chyba, https://cchyba.scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/cchyba/files/chybahand_araa2005.pdf
44. Astrobiology in Space: A Comprehensive Look at the Solar System – PMC, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10054531/
45. Exobiology | ASTROBIOLOGY @ NASA | Research, https://astrobiology.nasa.gov/research/astrobiology-at-nasa/exobiology/

Communication with Extraterrestrial Intelligence, https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/news-features/declassified-documents/cryptologic-spectrum/communications_with_extraterrestrial.pdf