Now we know that the amount of energy it takes to heat the milk separately is less than the energy to heat the coffee with the milk added, it stands to reason that it’s cheaper to heat the milk and then pour it into the coffee. Let’s see what Gemini has to say about this.
From a purely energy consumption (and thus cost) perspective, the most efficient approach is to heat the milk before pouring it into the coffee, if your goal is to have the hottest possible final mixture.
Here’s a breakdown of why:
-
Minimizing Heat Loss:
- Heating milk separately: When you heat the milk to 100°C (or close to it) in the microwave, it’s a smaller volume. While it heats up, it will lose some heat to the surroundings. However, the coffee is already at 100°C, and by adding the already hot milk, you minimize the immediate cooling of the coffee.
- Heating the mixture: If you pour the cold milk into the hot coffee first, the coffee immediately cools down to a lower equilibrium temperature (around 64°C in our previous calculation). Now you have a larger volume of liquid (500ml instead of 200ml) that needs to be heated from a lower starting temperature. A larger volume of liquid has more surface area (relatively) for heat loss to the environment during the longer heating time, and the heating efficiency of a microwave can vary with the load.
-
Microwave Efficiency:
- Microwaves are generally more efficient for heating smaller volumes of liquid. While the total energy required to raise the temperature of a given mass by a certain amount is theoretically the same regardless of how you do it, real-world microwave efficiency can drop with very small loads or change with very large loads.
- Some sources suggest that microwaves are around 50-70% efficient in converting electrical energy into heat in the food.
In summary:
- Heating milk then mixing: This method aims to preserve the heat of the coffee as much as possible. You’re heating the milk separately and then combining it, resulting in a hotter final beverage (assuming you don’t overheat the milk).
- Mixing then heating: This method means you’re heating a larger volume from a lower starting temperature. While the total energy change might be similar in a perfect system, the actual energy consumed by the microwave (and thus the cost) is likely to be slightly higher due to the longer run time and potential for increased heat loss from the larger volume over that longer period.
Therefore, for minimizing energy cost to get a hot beverage, heating the milk separately and then adding it to the coffee is generally the more efficient approach.
<<Should you let AI heat the milk for your coffee? And How Much Energy did Google Gemini use in finding this out?>>